Chris Christie Revenge Scandal Deepens a Day After Brash Governor Apologizes
Photo Credit: L.E.MORMILE / Shutterstock.com
The political revenge scandal surrounding New Jersey Republican Gov. Chris Christie has deepened as newly damaging documentation surfaced, federal prosecutors opened an investigation and a stunning new theory of what was going on emerged—suggesting that Christie loyalists were targeting the state Senate’s Democratic leader.
The cascade of damning evidence began with a striking 20-minute segment by MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow on Thursday night. Maddow made a plausible case that Christie’s deputy chief of staff and an appointee at the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey did not plan to shut down access to the George Washington Bridge during the first week of school last September because the Democratic mayor of Ft. Lee would not endorse his re-election. That explanation has been suggested in most media accounts, although Christie said he barely knew the city’s Democratic mayor when he apologized on Thursday.
Instead, Maddow showed that the e-mail from now-fired Deputy Chief of Staff Bridget Anne Kelly, “Time for some traffic problems in Ft. Lee,” written on Aug. 13, 2013, came a day after Christie called New Jersey Senate Democratic leaders “animals” in a bitter press conference. On Aug. 12, the governor said that he would not nominate a sitting New Jersey Supreme Court justice to a lifetime appointment because he did not want to subject her to a bruising legislative confirmation. The state Senate Democratic leader’s district included Ft. Lee, Maddow noted, saying that this revenge theory was more probable that Christie’s frustration over not getting a local endorsement.
Then, on Friday, newly damning documentation emerged suggesting that the shutdown might have violated state and federal law. A New Jersey Assembly investigation into the incident released several e-mail, including one from Port Authority executive director Patrick Foye that in part read, “I believe this hasty and ill-advised decision violated Federal Law and the laws of both states.” Foye said emergency vehicles were delayed, putting lives at risk. It hurt the economies of both states, came on a top Jewish holiday, subverted the public interest and hurt Port Authority’s reputation, he wrote. In response, another Christie appointee at the Authority, replied, “I am on my way to the office to discuss. There can be no public discourse.”
[pullquote]As usual, the media have been notoriously misleading (and flattering) in covering Christie. The coverage has been a long-running, and rather extreme, case of personality trumping substance.[/pullquote]
That e-mail is seen as suggesting a coverup was underway, where the Port Authority would say that it had been conducting a traffic study. Other documents said the closures only ended after protests by New York Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo. That follows reporting by the Wall Street Journal that said Christie complained in a phone call with Cuomo last month that the Port Authority was “pressing too hard” in its investigation.
Before Christie’s apology and press conference on Thursday where he announced he was firing Kelly and severing ties with others involved in the scandal, the state Assembly and Port Authority had been investigating the incident. On Thursday, the U.S. Attorney in New Jersey announced that it would determine if the lane closures were criminal.
The bottom line is the Christie revenge scandal is deepening and not about to go away soon. Some of that is because Christie has a deep reputation of being a political bully in his state and his opponents are not going to easily let him off the hook. The New York Times has covered many incidents where Christie has strong-armed opponents, including this week’sreport of a state environmental official who was told he might face legal consequences if he opposed a pipeline in one of the state’s most pristine area.
Beyond New Jersey’s border, national political reporters are well aware that Christie has been the leading Republican candidate in 2016 presidential polling. Both he and Hillary Clinton are their party’s leading candidates, and Christie also is the 2014 chairman of the Republican Governor’s Association. All of this means this scandal isn’t disappearing quietly into the night—if anything, it’s going to get louder and louder.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
How the Media Marketed Chris Christie’s Straight Shooter Charade
A political bombshell [2] detonated in my home state of New Jersey yesterday when published [3] emails and text messages revealed that Gov. Chris Christie’s deputy chief of staff conspired with a Christie transportation appointee to create a four-day traffic jam last September, allegedly to punish a local Democratic mayor who refused to endorse the governor’s re-election. The unfolding drama not only raises doubts about Christie’s political future but also about the way the mainstream press has presented him over the years.
The widening dirty tricks scandal features patronage [4] and political retribution wrapped in an unseemly culture of intimidation. In sharp contrast, the national political press has spent the last four years presenting, and even marketing, Christie as an above-the-fray politician who thrives on competence.
He’s been relentlessly and adoringly depicted as some sort of Straight Shooter. He’s an authentic and bipartisan Every Man, a master communicator [5], and that rare politician who cuts through the stagecraft and delivers hard truths. Christie’s coverage has been a long-running, and rather extreme, case of personality trumping substance.
But now the bridge bombshell casts all of that flattering coverage into question. How could the supposedly astute Beltway press corps spend four years selling Christie as a Straight Shooter when his close aides did things like orchestrate a massive traffic jam apparently to punish the governor’s political foes? When an appointee joked in texts about school buses being trapped in the political traffic backup? How could Christie be a Straight Shooter when he’s been caught peddling lies [6] about the unfolding scandal and now claims he wasmisled [7] about what people close to him were up to?
The truth is Christie was never the Straight Shooter that political reporters and pundits made him out to be. Not even close, as I’ll detail below. Instead, the Straight Shooter story represented appealing fiction for the press. They tagged him as “authentic” and loved it when he got into yelling matches with voters.
Media Matters recently rounded up [8] some of media’s Christie sweet talk, which is particularly enlightening to review in the wake of the Trenton scandal developments:
In the last month alone, TIME magazine has declared [9] that Christie governed with “kind of bipartisan dealmaking that no one seems to do anymore.” MSNBC’s Morning Joe called [10] the governor “different,” “fresh,” and “sort of a change from public people that you see coming out of Washington.” In a GQ profile, Christie was deemed [11] “that most unlikely of pols: a happy warrior,” while National Journal described [12] him as “the Republican governor with a can-do attitude” who “made it through 2013 largely unscathed. No scandals, no embarrassments or gaffes.” ABC’s Barbara Walters crowned[13] Christie as one of her 10 Most Fascinating People, casting him as a “passionate and compassionate” politician who cannot lie.
Note that when Christie last year easily won re-election against a weak Democratic opponent (via record low voter turnout [14]), the Beltway press treated the win as some sort of national coronation (“Chris Christie is a rock star” announced [15] CNN’s Carol Costello), with endless cable coverage and a round of softball interviews[16] on the Sunday political talk circuit.
Here’s Time from [17] last November’s celebration: “He’s a workhorse with a temper and a tongue, the guy who loves his mother and gets it done.” That, of course, is indistinguishable from a Christie office press release. But it’s been that way for years [18].
I detailed [19] some of that absurdly fawning coverage [20] in 2010 and 2011, but then I largely stopped writing about the phenomenon simply because it became clear that the press was entirely and unapologetically committed to peddling Christie press clippings. They liked the GOP story and it was one they wanted to tell, just like theyhad been wed [21] to the John-McCain-is-a-Maverick story. So they told it (selectively) over and over and over and over, regardless of the larger context about Christie actual behavior and his record as governor. (At one point under Christie in 2012, New Jersey’s unemployment hit a two year high that ranked among the highest [22] in the U.S.)
But again, the dreamt-up Straight Shooter storyline never reflected reality. Here are several examples drawn from just a 10-month stretch during Christie’s first term:
*In August of 2010, the state was shocked to discover it had narrowly missed out on $400 million worth of desperately needed education aid from the federal government because New Jersey’s application for the grant was flawed. Christie initially [23] tried to blame the Obama administration but that claim was shown to be false [24].
Christie’s own Education Commissioner then publicly blamed [25] Christie for the failure to land the money. He insisted the governor, who famously feuds with the state’s teacher unions, had placed that political battle and his right-wing credentials ahead of securing the federal funds and that Christie had told him the “money was not worth it” to the state if it meant he had to cooperate with teachers.
*In November 2010, the U.S. Department of Justice inspector general found [26] that while serving as U.S. attorney, Christie routinely billed taxpayers for luxury hotels on trips and failed to follow federal travel regulations.
*That December, Christie chose to leave New Jersey for a family vacation in Disney World even though forecasters had warned a blizzard was barreling towards the state, and even though Christie’s No. 2 was already out of the state visiting her ailing father. Worse, in the wake of the epic storm, Christie refused to return home early to help the state deal with the historic blizzard that left portions of the state buried under 30 inches of snow [27] and paralyzed for days. (The storm was so severe the Garden State had to appeal [27] to FEMA for $53 million in disaster aid.)
When Christie did return, he held a press conference [28] and blamed [29] state officials who didn’t escape to the Sunshine State for doing such a poor job managing the state’s emergency response. Bottom line: Christie said he wouldn’t have changed a thing because “I had a great five days with my children.”
*In May of 2011, Christie flew in a brand new, $12 million state-owned helicopter [30] to watch his son play a high school baseball game. After landing on a nearby football field, Christie was driven 300 feet in a black car with tinted windows to the baseball diamond. When he was done watching five innings, Christie boarded the helicopter and flew home. The trip cost $2,500 and Christie initially refused [31] to reimburse [32] the state for the expenses.
Keep in mind, these are all Christie tales that reporters and pundits almost pathologically omitted from their glowing profiles in recent years. Why? None of them fit within the narrow confines of the established narrative, so they were simply ignored.
Now with Christie’s political career reeling thanks to a shockingly vindictive and partisan scandal, it’s time for the press to drop the Straight Shooter charade.