Relevant Cinema: The Day the Earth Stood Still (1951)

Please share this article as widely as you can.

editors log bluePATRICE GREANVILLE

Despite its inevitable critical deficits, this is surely one of the most enduring and worthy sci-fi classics, notably made (considering its outspoken criticism of warmongering) right in the middle of the Cold War, a "war of choice" initiated by the West. In fact, this Hollywood product appeared at a time when the US was being plunged into a new manufactured anti-communist hysteria that would last more than four decades, and which of late has seamlessly transmogrified into a thinly veiled global war against Russia and China. Below, a comparative review by the Massie Twins, weighing the merits and weaknesses of the original vs its 2008 fancy remake.

Michael Rennie as Klaatu, the "spaceman" with a message and a warning to earthlings.

 

Genre: Sci-Fi Drama Running Time: 1 hr. 32 min.
Release Date: September 28th, 1951 MPAA Rating: Not Rated

Director: Robert Wise Actors: Michael Rennie, Patricia Neal, Hugh Marlowe, Sam Jaffe, Frances Bavier

Review

Asaucer-like spacecraft lands in Washington, D.C., capturing the attention of denizens across the globe. Humanoid emissary Klaatu (Michael Rennie) emerges with an immediate introduction of peace and goodwill – alongside his intimidating, hulking, 8-foot robot bodyguard Gort – but is accidentally shot while presenting an exotic gift. As the military takes control of the situation by rushing Klaatu to a hospital and confining him to a cell, the strange visitor decides he must intermingle with other humans to help him with his ultimate mission: to warn the leaders of the world that total obliteration awaits if human aggression and violence are not put to a halt.

After escaping from his quarters and assuming the name of Mr. Carpenter, Klaatu rents a room adjacent to Helen Benson (Patricia Neal) and her inquisitive young son Bobby (Billy Gray). He interacts with them to experience the decency and reasoning humankind can exhibit, which the strict, unfriendly, regimented U.S. war machine could not offer. When Klaatu arranges a meeting with the top scientists in the nation, jealousy and paranoia from Helen’s boyfriend (Hugh Marlowe) lead to further military intervention.

In the 1951 classic, alien visitor Klaatu arrives simply to deliver a message – one that leaves the fate of the planet in the hands of the people yet cautions them to govern with moral proprieties. In the 2008 remake, Klaatu arrives for a different reason: he must pass judgment over the guilty as well as carry out an execution. The differences in his purpose cause both films to head toward drastically contrasting plot directions. But what is most surprising about the update is the removal of almost everything creative, allegorical, and thought-provoking devised in the original.

Writer Edmund H. North’s adaptation (of the short story “Farewell to the Master” by Harry Bates) proves that an intelligent, well-written script can easily make up for a lack in visual luster. A few visible wires, a crash of cymbals to replace onscreen intensity, and a clunky robot design (which is now famously iconic) are quickly forgiven as an engaging storyline and memorable characters fill the void of what would nowadays be computer-augmented special effects. While some accuse “The Day the Earth Stood Still” of preaching messages over-delivering thrills, it’s a frequently recognized science-fiction staple of alien invaders, the near-miss engaging of failsafe switches for out-of-control technological dependence, and a prescient warning of the decline of civilized international cooperation.

– The Massie Twins

The views expressed herein are solely those of the author and may or may not reflect those of  The Greanville Post. However, we do think they are important enough to be transmitted to a wider audience. 

All image captions, pull quotes, appendices, etc. by the editors not the authors. 
YOU ARE FREE TO REPRODUCE THIS ARTICLE PROVIDED YOU GIVE PROPER CREDIT TO THE GREANVILLE POST VIA A BACK LIVE LINK. 
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License

[premium_newsticker id="211406"]

 Don't forget to sign up for our FREE bulletin. Get The Greanville Post in your mailbox every few days.