Bamford demonstrates how the American counterintelligence apparatus has become a paper tiger vulnerable to sabotage and its susceptibility has not been limited to subversion by ideological adversaries like Cuba. While geo-political rivals in Moscow and Beijing have been among the expected offenders in spy scandals as well, Spyfailalso shows how many of Washington’s allies and partners have been behind spycraft against the U.S.—with politicians and the yellow press turning a blind eye. Given the revelations by National Security Agency (NSA) whistleblower Edward Snowden of the extent of Washington’s own eavesdropping on members of the Atlantic alliance, it is not that surprising. However, one country in particular has been able to evade scrutiny as the source of numerous espionage operations violating American national security for just as long as Rocha is said to have been a mole for Havana.
Dominating the headlines in the intervening months of the Rocha case has been Israel’s ongoing genocide in Gaza. For the same reason that the Zionist entity maintains unconditional U.S. assistance and favorable coverage in legacy media as it slaughters Palestinians, Tel Aviv enjoys virtual immunity over its repeated cloak-and-dagger transgressions of American sovereignty—the immense power of the Israel Lobby over Congress and the media. Perhaps the most infamous case was that of Jonathan Pollard, a naval intelligence analyst who was convicted of spying and passing highly confidential data to the Jewish state in the mid-1980s. Like Rocha, Pollard was jailed after negotiating a plea bargain, but the U.S.-Israel “special relationship” itself never came into question. Meanwhile, Bamford sheds light on another scandal involving an Israeli spook that did not receive nearly as much attention while the agent at the center eluded incrimination altogether.
Just a few months before Pollard was charged with violating the Espionage Act, a California aerospace engineer and NASA consultant named Richard Kelly Smyth was indicted by the FBI for unlawfully exporting more than a dozen shipments of “krytrons”—devices used as triggers to fire nuclear bombs—to Israel in the early 1980s. The illicit consignments were made through an intermediary in “former” Israeli spy and Hollywood film mogul Arnon Milchan, whose production credits include Pretty Woman,L.A. Confidential, and Fight Club. Unlike Pollard, Smyth escaped to Spain before his trial began and avoided capture until INTERPOL finally apprehended the fugitive physicist in 2001 for extradition back to Los Angeles. (In spite of an official policy refusing to confirm or deny the possession of a nuclear stockpile, it is widely accepted that the existence of a clandestine Israeli program goes back to the 1950s.)
Smyth served no time in prison as he was immediately paroled because of his advanced age (72), and the Israeli agent whose front company facilitated the entire smuggling ring was never prosecuted and to this day remains a fixture in Tinseltown. In fact, Milchan’s double life as a weapons trafficker only seemed to propel his success as a film magnate. Despite producing propaganda for apartheid South Africa while supplying Pretoria with arms and military technology in exchange for yellowcake uranium to enrich Israeli nukes, Milchan later financed the Oscar-nominated 12 Years a Slave (2014). Even though the billionaire producer candidly owned up to being a LAKAM operative—the same top-secret unit that recruited Jonathan Pollard—it was only when Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was brought up on corruption charges that Milchan’s name stirred controversy.
Still ongoing in the midst of the war in Gaza, Bibi’s graft trial involves allegations from a decade ago that he and his wife accepted bribes and lavish gifts from Milchan in order to pressure the Obama administration into securing the latter a U.S. visa, which then-Secretary of State John Kerry obliged. Netanyahu also proposed domestic legislation that gave tax breaks to returning wealthy Israelis such as the movie tycoon for “making Aliyah” (Jews who emigrate to Israel) in what became known as “Milchan’s Law.” According to Bamford, the close friendship between the two men precedes Netanyahu’s tenure as head of state back to his early career at the Israeli Embassy in Washington where he negotiated for Milchan’s immunity in the Smyth case.
When the national security state has not overlooked spies hiding in plain sight or neglected to prosecute those employed by “friendly” countries, it has framed innocent people to fit political narratives. Bamford was one of the few, if not the only journalist to uncover the truth about one of the most notorious international spy cases in recent years—which turned out not to be a case of espionage at all. Not since the Cold War has foreign intrigue generated so many headlines as the special counsel investigation into alleged collusion between Donald Trump and the Russian government during the 2016 U.S. presidential election. Like the Red Scare, the paranoia surrounding the Mueller probe resulted in scapegoats but none more so than a fiery redhead from Siberia residing in D.C. on a student visa, who was persecuted amidst the neo-McCarthyite atmosphere.
Just a few months shy of her 30th birthday, Maria Butina had just graduated from American University in the nation’s capital during the summer of 2018 when she was taken into custody by the FBI. Held for months in solitary confinement, the Russian-born international relations major was charged with conspiracy to act as an unregistered foreign agent. In addition to her master’s studies, Butina was a gun rights activist in the Motherland and partly came to Washington to build a bridge with the American gun lobby. Even though her advocacy of the right to bear arms made her a dissident within the Russian Federation where firearms are heavily restricted, she somehow became portrayed as the conduit of illicit funds supposedly being funneled from the Kremlin to the Trump campaign via the National Rifle Association (NRA). As if that were not bad enough, the most malicious slander was that she was a Red Sparrow-esque honeypot who traded sex with GOP operatives and NRA figures to advance Moscow’s interests, all based on a few sarcastic text messages.
The presumed connection linking Butina to the Kremlin was through Aleksandr Torshin, a Russian central banker and senator in the Duma, who was also a hunting enthusiast and gun advocate. When Butina established a Moscow-based, pro-gun organization in 2011, Torshin was one of its earliest supporters. However, the Vladimir Putin administration rejected any legislative attempts to relax gun-control laws domestically. Trump-era National Security Adviser John Bolton, one of the most Russophobic militarists in Washington, even appeared in one of their ads. Butina then came to the U.S. and made contacts with Second Amendment groups while enrolled in graduate school. Despite no evidence to show that she was working for either Torshin or the Russian state, the media began publishing hearsay that she was a sleeper agent who infiltrated special-interest groups to establish a back-channel with Trump.
If Butina really was on the Kremlin payroll, no explanation was given as to why she needed to seek financial assistance to cover school tuition from her boyfriend of several years, Republican political consultant Paul Erickson. She also borrowed money from George D. O’Neill, Jr., a Rockefeller heir and op-ed writer for TheAmerican Conservative who penned articles advocating rapprochement between Washington and Moscow. A paleoconservative outsider, O’Neill had previously worked with Erickson on Pat Buchanan’s unsuccessful 1992 Republican primary challenge of George H. W. Bush. After being introduced to Butina, he invited the ginger-haired grad student and her mentor Torshin to the National Prayer Breakfast and other GOP get-togethers in the hopes of improving U.S.-Russia relations. The closest in proximity Butina ever came to the Trump camp was his foreign policy adviser J. D. Gordon, but their interactions were limited to attending a rock concert together and exchanging a handful of emails a few months prior to the 2016 election.
A year earlier, Butina did manage to publicly ask the soon-to-be 45th president about potential U.S.-Russia cooperation just a month into his controversial candidacy at a libertarian convention in Las Vegas. Trump replied he was open to dropping the sanctions placed on Moscow by the Obama administration, which he claimed were pushing Russia into closer relations with China. Such heretical statements which broke from foreign policy orthodoxy made him a marked man and the Russophobic hysteria would reach a fever pitch by the time he assumed office. The day before Trump finally met his Russian counterpart as commander-in-chief at the July 2018 Helsinki summit, Butina’s apartment was raided by the feds. Earlier that week, 12 Russian GRU intelligence officers were separately indicted in absentia for allegedly hacking the Democratic National Committee (DNC) computer server. (The cybersecurity firm which blamed Moscow for the email leaks, CrowdStrike, was itself recently responsible for a global software outage. Citing incidents such as the 2014 Sony Pictures hack attributed to North Korea using stolen NSA spy tools, Spyfail shows how cyberattacks are another area in which the U.S. is increasingly exposed.)
Although she was questioned by special prosecutor and former FBI Director Robert Mueller over her association with Gordon, Butina’s case was never part of his two-year inquiry. Prior to her arrest, Butina had already testified before the Senate Intelligence Committee on her activities. None of this prevented the fourth estate from branding the 29-year-old Russian national a spy before she had even been swooped up by the authorities. Prosecutors knew perfectly well that Butina had not committed espionage, so they settled for the single charge of being an undeclared foreign agent. Most of the media lazily assumed this meant she had violated the Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA), when it was under an entirely different statute (Title 18 U.S.C. § 951). In short, Butina naively failed to turn in bureaucratic paperwork and was convicted on a technicality.
Coincidentally, Jim Bamford had personally encountered Butina years prior to her notoriety while attending a conference on the Middle East as a columnist for Foreign Policy magazine. As a leading expert on intelligence, he knew the claims about her were false. After spending the majority of her year-and-a-half sentence in a Florida prison, Butina was deported by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) back to Moscow where she has since successfully run for Russian parliament. In the end, the Mueller Report showed no proof the Trump campaign ever conspired with the Kremlin, but the establishment goal of criminalizing détente between two nuclear-armed powers was achieved. Butina’s name did not appear a single time in the 448-page document, but she was still put through a misogynistic character assassination and made a political prisoner.
One of the biggest propagandists of the Russiagate hoax was neo-conservative pundit Max Boot of The Washington Post. In July 2024, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) issued two counts against Boot’s wife, Sue Mi Terry, an ex-CIA analyst and senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, for acting as an agent-of-influence on behalf of South Korea’s National Intelligence Service (NIS). A self-proclaimed expert on the DPRK, Terry received payments with undisclosed payoffs, expensive dinners and designer handbags to advance ROK government positions in the media. The unsealed indictment also alleges Terry used her prestige at various think tanks on a quid pro quo basis to share private information with NIS officers and arrange exclusive meetings between South Korean and U.S. officials, without registering under FARA. She even acknowledged handing over notes from an off-the-record briefing with Secretary of State Antony Blinken over to her handlers. Although Terry co-authored editorials with her husband on Korean matters, Boot himself has not been implicated thus far—but it appears everything the arch-neo-con had to say about Trump and Butina applies much more to his own spouse.
Boot referred to Butina as “just the tip of the Russian iceberg” when in fact, it is his wife’s case which does not even scratch the surface of widespread influence peddling by Washington’s purported allies. The corruption charges against Democratic Senator Bob Menendez of New Jersey for accepting bribes from the Egyptian and Qatari regimes, as well as the grand jury subpoenas of New York City Mayor Eric Adams for receiving kickbacks and unlawful campaign donations from businesses tied to the Turkish government, are just a few examples.
As Bamford observed, while the federal witch-hunt was focused on Moscow in 2016, the United Arab Emirates and other Gulf monarchies were pouring millions in dirty-money contributions into both the Hillary Clinton and Trump campaigns by way of a shady lobbyist and convicted pedophile named George Nader. Not to mention that Benjamin Netanyahu sent a secret Israeli agent to the U.S. to provide Trump aide Roger Stone with advanced knowledge of the damaging intel leaked from the DNC to WikiLeaks.
As American hegemony continues to decline, U.S. national security is more and more unprotected from intrusion and subterfuge. Spyfail chronicles the miserable failures by the intelligence community, despite a gargantuan defense budget, at stopping foreign plots, whether by declared enemies or close allies, while squandering investigative and prosecutorial resources to fabricate charges against blameless individuals to suit political agendas. Due to a combination of hapless incompetence and corruption, the spymasters responsible have only been rewarded with promotions. Russiagate even helped several officials, including James Clapper and John Brennan, land nightly news gigs where they have kept up the CIA tradition of playing the media like its “Mighty Wurlitzer.” Such stenography has resulted in outrageous propaganda such as the disputed claim that American personnel at the U.S. Embassy in Cuba were falling ill due to Russian sonic weaponry, when the more likely cause of so-called “Havana Syndrome” turned out to be the mating cries of crickets.
When BBC News reported on the Rocha story, former CIA Chief of Counterintelligence James Olson revived the slander that the late CovertAction Information Bulletin founder and ex-CIA case officer Philip Agee was among the list of past spies “run” by Cuba. A true patriot if there ever was one, Agee blew the whistle on the agency’s various criminal activities around the world in his seminal 1975 bookInside the Company: CIA Diary and the powers that be have never forgiven him.
Although he was not a double agent, Agee would have been the first to retort that Cuba has been forced to use any means necessary to defend itself from more than 60 years of economic blockade and consecutive U.S. administrations terrorizing the island in their attempts to topple the communist government. As long as it continues to perpetuate such injustices throughout the globe, the empire will always be inviting the next Manuel Rocha.
CovertAction Magazine is made possible by subscriptions, orders and donations from readers like you.
Blow the Whistle on U.S. Imperialism
Click the whistle and donate
Dialogue Works
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License • 
